James Phillips: Soleimani strike the right call to make
Guest Commentary

James Phillips: Soleimani strike the right call to make


A lot of hand-wringing followed the U.S. airstrike that killed Iranian Gen. Qassem Soleimani - and it became even worse in the wake of Iran's Jan. 7 missile strikes.

Many have questioned what evidence, if any, indicated the general was planning an "imminent attack" on U.S. forces, as Secretary of State Mike Pompeo called it.

But even if such evidence was "razor thin," as the New York Times reported, this airstrike was indeed the right call to make. It's also one that shouldn't have surprised Iranian officials one bit, unless they had ignored President Donald Trump's repeated warnings against killing Americans.

Soleimani was no angel, to put it mildly. For many years, he was the mastermind behind Iran's low-intensity warfare and terrorist campaign against the U.S. and its allies. As the leader of the Quds Force, the elite special-operations wing of Iran's Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, Soleimani essentially served as Iran's viceroy for Iraq, Syria and Lebanon.

He rose to prominence inside Iran and in the region by supervising Iran's expanding network of surrogate militias, terrorist groups and radical Islamist allies.

His Quds Force orchestrated the formation, arming, training and operations of a foreign legion of Iraqi, Syrian, Lebanese, Afghan, Yemeni and other militant groups that Tehran has deployed to advance its imperial agenda and to export Iran's Islamist revolution.

Iran long has used surrogate militias to do its dirty work in Iraq. One of the terrorists killed along with Soleimani was Abu Mahdi al-Muhandis, the leader of Kataib Hezbollah ("Brigades of the Party of God").

Like Soleimani, al-Muhandis was designated as a terrorist by the United States. He was convicted and condemned to death in absentia in Kuwait for his involvement in the 1983 bombings of the U.S. and French embassies in Kuwait City.

This radical Iraqi militia - modeled on Lebanon's Hezbollah terrorist militia (which Soleimani also helped to build up) - was formed in 2007 as a proxy group under the direct command of Soleimani's Quds Force. Kataib Hezbollah was one of the Iraqi militias that the Quds Force employed to kill more than 600 U.S. troops in Iraq from 2003 to 2011, according to Pentagon estimates.

Kataib Hezbollah also was responsible for numerous rocket attacks in recent months on U.S. troops in Iraq, including the Dec. 27 rocket attack that killed an American citizen and provoked the current crisis. The U.S. retaliated for the rocket attack with airstrikes against five Kataib Hezbollah bases and weapons-storage sites in Iraq and Syria on Dec. 29.

This prompted Kataib Hezbollah and other Iran-backed militias to mobilize a mob that besieged the U.S. Embassy in Baghdad on Dec. 30-31 and tried to set it on fire. Soleimani arrived at Baghdad airport shortly thereafter, undoubtedly planning to orchestrate more dangerous attacks on U.S. personnel in Iraq.

Soleimani's death is a huge loss for Iran's regime and its Iraqi proxies. It also is a major operational and psychological victory for the United States.

The strong U.S. military response and demonstrated intelligence capacity to identify, track and target Soleimani's movements should bolster U.S. deterrence of Iranian aggression in the long run, although Iran is likely to escalate attacks in Iraq and elsewhere in the immediate aftermath of the strike.

But as Secretary of Defense Mark Esper said before the U.S. strike: "The game has changed." Washington will no longer tolerate attacks by Iran-backed proxy groups without inflicting a heavy price, not only on them, but on Iran, which historically has acted with impunity by conducting a shadow war through surrogates.

This policy of holding Tehran accountable for the attacks of its proxies was announced by the White House in a 2018 statement, after Iranian-backed Iraqi militias attacked American diplomatic facilities in Iraq:

"Over the past few days, we have seen life-threatening attacks in Iraq, including on the United States Consulate in Basra and against the American Embassy compound in Baghdad. Iran did not act to stop these attacks by its proxies in Iraq, which it has supported with funding, training, and weapons.

"The United States will hold the regime in Tehran accountable for any attack that results in injury to our personnel or damage to United States government facilities. America will respond swiftly and decisively in defense of American lives."

Trump has repeatedly warned Iranian leaders about the potential consequences of attacks on Americans. It should be no surprise that he enforced his own "red line."

The successful strike against Soleimani is a powerful message to Iranian leaders that their old tactics of "fighting to the last Iraqi" in a shadow war against the U.S. now entail many more risks and costs. If sustained over time, that could alter their cost-benefit calculus and lead them to moderate their hostile and aggressive policies.

In short, the conflict with Iran will continue, but World War III is not imminent.

James Phillips is a senior research fellow for Middle Eastern affairs at The Heritage Foundation (heritage.org).


Be the first to know

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

GUEST COMMENTARY It is a sign of our times that Attorney General William Barr tried to do something right and some illiberal liberals, including not a few in the media, decided that it was wrong on the basis of mindless presidential squawks, factual ignorance and in some cases political opportunity.

  • Updated

DAN WALTERS Gavin Newsom is rushing in where angels — and more cautious politicians — fear to tread by devoting virtually all of his second State of the State address to California’s seemingly intractable housing and homelessness crises.

KEVIN MERRILL I remember when I was around 20 and we used to listen to the radio while hauling hay. Occasionally there would be a weekend during which the station would have a British Invasion theme. I always remember the song, “When Im 64” by the Beatles. We would sing along with the radio, “will you still need me, will you still feed me, when Im 64?” When you’re 20 years old, 64 seems a long way away.

MARK JAMES MILLER Having a roof over your head is one of the most basic of needs. If people are going to have a chance at rising to their highest level, Maslow’s “self-actualization,” and thus contribute to society, they must have a place to live.

Kudos to the Manhattan district attorney's office, and particularly to lead prosecutor Joan Illuzzi-Orbon and her team, on getting a guilty verdict in the Harvey Weinstein case. As we all recognize, the case was a major challenge. Placing this verdict in historical perspective makes it even more significant. Until the early 1970s, virtually no sex crimes case could be prosecuted because of ...

KEVIN G. WALTHERS Over the course of the next few months, Hancock College will roll out a new initiative to ensure that no student feels his or her best option is to take on insurmountable debt to earn a college credential. Our commitment to you is that we will increase our outreach presence and configure our programs in a manner that ensures everyone in our community can affordably pursue their educational goals.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


News Alerts

Breaking News